haya.Learning made clear
Leadership: early, contingency and contemporary theories sheet
Essay frame

Explain the contingency theories of leadership.

How to lay out the answer. Follow the frame, then write it in your own words.

  1. 1 · Open. Trait and behavioural theories could not find one best style. Contingency theories say the best style depends on the situation.
  2. 2 · Fiedler's contingency model.
    • Style measured by the LPC questionnaire: task- or relationship-oriented, and fixed.
    • Situation: leader-member relations, task structure, position power.
    • Task-oriented leaders suit very favourable or very unfavourable situations; relationship-oriented leaders suit moderate ones.
  3. 3 · Hersey and Blanchard's situational theory.
    • Readiness = the ability and willingness of followers.
    • R1 telling, R2 selling, R3 participating, R4 delegating.
  4. 4 · Draw the situational model. [2×2 grid: task behaviour across, relationship behaviour up; telling, selling, participating and delegating in the four boxes, linked to R1-R4]
  5. 5 · Path-goal theory. Robert House: directive, supportive, participative or achievement-oriented behaviour, chosen to fit the environment and the followers.
  6. 6 · In Sri Lankan business. An apparel supervisor tells a new operator, sells to a keen trainee, participates with a skilled but demotivated worker and delegates to a veteran.
  7. 7 · Evaluate. Strength: realistic and situation-based. Weakness: Fiedler assumes style cannot change; readiness is hard to measure.
  8. 8 · Close. Effective leaders read the situation and their followers before choosing how to lead.

Scoring tip: Get the authors right: Fiedler uses LPC and three situational factors; Hersey and Blanchard use follower readiness. Mixing them up costs marks.