The search for the genetic material: DNA is the genetic material
Griffith found a transforming principle; Avery, MacLeod and McCarty showed it was DNA; Hershey and Chase proved with phages that DNA is the genetic material.
Griffith's transformation experiment (1928)
Griffith used two strains of the bacterium Streptococcus pneumoniae. The **S strain** forms **smooth, shiny colonies** because of a polysaccharide coat (capsule). The **R strain** forms **rough colonies** and has no coat.
- 1Live S strain injected into mice → mice die of pneumonia. S is virulent.
- 2Live R strain injected → mice live.
- 3Heat-killed S strain injected → mice live.
- 4★Heat-killed S + live R injected → mice die, and living S bacteria are recovered from them.
- 5Conclusion: some 'transforming principle' passed from the dead S bacteria and changed R into S. This change was genetic, but its chemical nature was not known.
★ key step
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty: naming the transforming principle
These workers purified the proteins, DNA and RNA of heat-killed S bacteria. Only DNA changed R bacteria into S. Proteases (protein-digesting enzymes) and RNases did not stop the change, but DNase (DNA-digesting enzyme) did. So the transforming principle was DNA. Not all biologists were convinced, so firmer proof was needed.
Hershey and Chase: the blender experiment (1952)
**Bacteriophages** are viruses that infect bacteria. A phage is made of DNA inside a protein coat.
- 1Some phages were grown on a medium with radioactive phosphorus (³²P). This labels DNA, because protein has no phosphorus.
- 2Other phages were grown with radioactive sulphur (³⁵S). This labels protein, because DNA has no sulphur.
- 3Each kind of phage was allowed to infect E. coli bacteria.
- 4Blending: the mixture was shaken in a blender to strip the phage coats off the bacteria.
- 5Centrifugation: the heavier bacteria settled as a pellet; the lighter phage coats stayed in the liquid (supernatant).
- 6★Result: with ³²P, the bacteria were radioactive; with ³⁵S, the radioactivity was in the supernatant, not the bacteria. So DNA, not protein, entered the bacteria: DNA is the genetic material.
★ key step
DNA vs RNA as the genetic material
Both can carry genetic information: in some viruses, such as tobacco mosaic virus and Qβ bacteriophage, RNA is the genetic material.
The RNA world
RNA was the first genetic material. Key life processes, such as metabolism, translation and splicing, evolved around RNA. Early RNA acted both as the genetic material and as a catalyst; some reactions in cells are still catalysed by RNA. But a reactive catalyst is unstable as a store of information. So DNA evolved from RNA, with chemical changes that made it more stable. Its double helix and complementary strands also allow it to resist change and be repaired.
Scientists now use transformation on purpose: they put the human insulin gene into bacteria, which then make insulin for people with diabetes.
3 marks: “Describe Griffith's experiment. What did it show?” S strain (capsule, virulent) kills mice; R strain does not; heat-killed S does not; heat-killed S + live R kills, and live S is recovered. A transforming principle from dead S changed R into S; the change was genetic.
3 marks: “Why did Hershey and Chase use ³²P and ³⁵S? What did they conclude?” ³²P labels DNA (DNA has phosphorus, protein does not); ³⁵S labels protein (protein has sulphur, DNA does not). After infection, blending and centrifugation, only ³²P was found inside bacteria. So DNA enters the cell and is the genetic material.
2 marks: “Give two reasons why DNA is a better genetic material than RNA.” DNA is more stable: it lacks the reactive 2′-OH group and has thymine instead of uracil. Being double-stranded, it can repair damage and changes slowly.
Phosphorus labels the Polynucleotide (DNA); Sulphur labels the Shell (protein coat).