Origin of life
Life most likely began in the early oceans by chemical evolution: simple gases formed organic molecules, which later formed the first cells. Miller's experiment supported this idea.
Ideas about where life came from
| Idea | What it says | Status today |
|---|---|---|
| Special creation | All living things were created as they are now and have not changed | Rejected; evidence shows life has changed over time |
| Panspermia | Spores or units of life came to Earth from other planets | A few scientists still favour it |
| Spontaneous generation (abiogenesis) | Life arises on its own from decaying matter such as straw and mud | Disproved by Louis Pasteur |
| Chemical evolution (Oparin and Haldane) | First life came from non-living organic molecules such as RNA and proteins, formed from inorganic substances | Accepted by most scientists |
Pasteur: life comes only from life
Louis Pasteur boiled a broth of killed yeast in flasks. In pre-sterilised flasks kept closed, no life appeared. In a flask open to air, new microbes grew. So life did not arise on its own from dead matter; it came from pre-existing life carried in the air. This ended the theory of spontaneous generation.
From a hot Earth to the first cells
- 1The Big Bang formed the universe, which your textbook gives as almost 13.8 billion years old. Galaxies and the solar system formed later.
- 2The Earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago. At first it had no atmosphere.
- 3Water vapour, methane, carbon dioxide and ammonia came out of the molten mass. UV rays split water into hydrogen and oxygen; the light hydrogen escaped.Oxygen combined with ammonia and methane to form water and CO₂; an ozone layer formed
- 4As the Earth cooled, water vapour fell as rain and filled hollows to form oceans.
- 5★With high temperature, lightning and a reducing atmosphere, simple molecules joined to form organic molecules such as amino acids and sugars.This is chemical evolution
- 6Non-cellular life (giant molecules such as RNA and proteins, perhaps inside capsules) arose about 3 billion years ago.
- 7The first cellular life, probably single cells living in water, arose about 2 billion years ago.
★ key step
Miller's experiment (1953)
**S.L. Miller**, an American scientist, tested the Oparin-Haldane idea in the laboratory.
- 1He took a closed flask with CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour, copying the early reducing atmosphere.
- 2He kept the mixture at 800 °C and passed electric sparks through it, copying lightning.
- 3A condenser cooled the gases so that liquid collected below, like rain into the sea.
- 4★After about a week the liquid contained amino acids.
- 5Similar experiments by others gave sugars, nitrogen bases, pigments and fats. Meteorites also contain such compounds, so the same process may happen elsewhere in space.
★ key step
How to draw Miller's apparatus
- Draw a large round spark chamber at the top with two electrodes going in; label it with CH₄, NH₃, H₂ and water vapour.
- Draw a tube leading down to a condenser (a jacket with cold water in and out).
- Below the condenser, draw a U-shaped trap where liquid collects; label water with organic compounds.
- Draw a small flask of boiling water with a heat source, joined back to the spark chamber by a tube.
- Add arrows to show the gases moving round the loop, and label electric discharge at the electrodes.
Pasteur showed that life comes only from life. That is why we boil milk, pressure-cook food and sterilise surgical tools in Indian hospitals: once the microbes are killed, no new ones appear unless they get in from outside.
2 marks: “Why did spontaneous generation have to be given up? Name the scientist who disproved it.” Louis Pasteur showed that in pre-sterilised closed flasks, killed yeast gave no life, while a flask open to air grew microbes. So life comes only from pre-existing life.
3 marks: “Describe Miller's experiment. What did it show?” Closed flask with CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour at 800 °C; electric discharge; condenser collected liquid; amino acids formed. It supported chemical evolution as proposed by Oparin and Haldane.
5 marks: “Explain the theory of chemical evolution of life. How did Miller's experiment support it? Draw his apparatus.” Oparin and Haldane: early Earth, reducing atmosphere, energy from lightning and heat, organic molecules, non-cellular then cellular life. Miller's set-up and result. Labelled apparatus diagram.
Miller's gases are MAHW: Methane, Ammonia, Hydrogen, Water vapour, plus a spark at 800 °C.