Stereochemistry of substitution: optical activity, retention, inversion and racemisation
A chiral molecule is not superimposable on its mirror image. SN2 on a chiral carbon causes inversion; SN1 causes racemisation, because the flat carbocation is attacked from both sides.
Optical activity
Ordinary light vibrates in all planes. Passing it through a Nicol prism gives plane polarised light, which vibrates in one plane only. Some compounds rotate this plane; they are optically active. The angle of rotation is measured with a polarimeter. A compound that turns the plane to the right (clockwise) is dextrorotatory (d or +). One that turns it to the left is laevorotatory (l or −). The d and l forms of a compound are called optical isomers.
Chirality and enantiomers
- An object that is not superimposable on its mirror image is chiral, like your left and right hands. One that is superimposable is achiral.
- A carbon joined to four different groups is an asymmetric carbon or stereocentre. A molecule with one such carbon is chiral.
- Butan-2-ol, CH₃CH(OH)CH₂CH₃, is chiral: C-2 carries H, OH, CH₃ and C₂H₅. Propan-2-ol, CH₃CH(OH)CH₃, is achiral: C-2 carries two CH₃ groups.
- Enantiomers are the two non-superimposable mirror-image forms. They have the same physical properties, except that they rotate plane polarised light by equal amounts in opposite directions.
- A racemic mixture has equal amounts of both enantiomers. Their rotations cancel, so it is optically inactive. Turning one enantiomer into a racemic mixture is racemisation.
Retention, inversion and racemisation
| Term | What happens at the chiral carbon | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Retention | The arrangement of bonds round the chiral carbon stays the same, usually because no bond to that carbon breaks | (−)-2-Methylbutan-1-ol + HCl, heat → (+)-1-chloro-2-methylbutane (the sign changes, but the arrangement is kept) |
| Inversion | The new group takes the position opposite to the leaving group, so the arrangement flips | SN2: (−)-2-bromooctane + OH⁻ → (+)-octan-2-ol |
| Racemisation | A 50:50 mixture of the retained and inverted products forms | SN1: optically active 2-bromobutane + OH⁻ → (±)-butan-2-ol |
Why SN1 gives racemisation
- 1R-X → R⁺ + X⁻The optically active alkyl halide ionises in the slow step
- 2★The carbocation is sp² hybridised and planar (flat), so it is achiral.
- 3The nucleophile can attack the flat carbocation from either face, about equally often.
- 4Attack from the front gives the retained product; attack from the back gives the inverted product. A roughly 50:50 mixture forms, so the rotations cancel.
★ key step
How to draw inversion in an SN2 reaction
- Draw the chiral carbon with three groups, using one wedge (towards you) and one dash (away from you), and X on the right.
- Draw the nucleophile (OH⁻) on the left, with a curved arrow from it to the carbon, and another from the C-X bond to X.
- Draw the transition state in square brackets: HO···C···X with dotted bonds and the three groups in one flat plane.
- Draw the product with OH on the left and the three groups flipped to the right, like an umbrella blown inside out.
- Label: backside attack, transition state, inversion of configuration.
Many medicines are chiral, and often only one enantiomer works well; the other may do nothing or even cause harm. So medicine makers choose reactions that give inversion or retention, not a racemic mixture.
2 marks: “What is a racemic mixture? Why is it optically inactive?” An equimolar mixture of the d and l enantiomers. They rotate the plane of polarised light equally in opposite directions, so the rotations cancel.
3 marks: “Optically active 2-bromobutane gives an optically inactive alcohol by SN1, but (−)-2-bromooctane gives (+)-octan-2-ol by SN2. Explain both.” SN1: planar sp² carbocation, attack from both faces, about 50:50 retained and inverted products, racemic. SN2: backside attack in one step, so only the inverted alcohol forms.
1 marks: “Which is chiral: butan-2-ol or propan-2-ol?” Butan-2-ol: its C-2 carries four different groups (H, OH, CH₃, C₂H₅).
SN2 flips, SN1 mixes, and breaking no bond at the chiral carbon keeps it.